2014 MTV VMAs Air Tonight / Who Should Win, Who Will Win

Look, you know you care. You do. You’ll watch them. You’ll discuss them. You’ll post a witticism about Nicki Minaj and a snake. You’ll hope for the occasional disaster. Maybe you’ll even get it (see snake, bites). But, more likely you’ll get the 31st incarnation of the award show that basically defined the modern music award show — lots of performances, few awards — and that should dominate your conversations and your timeline.

Tune into MTV at 9/8c... And keep pegged to my @videostatic Twitter for updates from The Forum and more...

In the meantime, here's who I think should win... and who will win. 

VIDEO OF THE YEAR:

  • Iggy Azalea f/ Charli XCX "Fancy" (Director X, dir.)
  • Beyoncé f/ JAY Z "Drunk In Love" (Hype Williams, dir.)
  • Pharrell Williams "Happy" (We Are From L.A., dir.)
  • Sia "Chandelier" (Sia & Daniel Askill, dir.)
  • Miley Cyrus "Wrecking Ball" (Terry Richardson, dir.)

Should Win: I still say “Turn Down For What” is the best video of the year, but it can’t win, and not just because it’s not nominated. Awards at this level celebrate celebrity and/or create stars. Do you even know what DJ Snake looks like? He could be an actual snake for all you know. If anyone collected that Moonman, it would be co-director/star Daniel Kwan’s crotch. And as awesome as that would be, it would never happen.

Will Win: Iggy Azalea f/ Charli XCX “Fancy” represents the new generation of MTV stars and this could be their latest and biggest coronation. I wouldn't be surprised if Pharrell wins, because, well, he's Pharrell and all he do is win.

BEST HIP HOP:

Should Win: Childish Gambino, even if for no other reason than that “3005” is his best video to date, whereas all the other nominees have had clearly better and/or more popular videos.

Will Win: Eminem.  

BEST MALE:

  • Pharrell Williams "Happy" (We Are From L.A., dir.)
  • John Legend "All Of Me" (NABIL, dir.)
  • Ed Sheeran f/ Pharrell "Sing" (Emil Nava, dir.)
  • Sam Smith "Stay With Me" (Jamie Thraves, dir.)
  • Eminem f/ Rihanna "Monster" (Rich Lee, dir.)

Should Win: Pharrell Williams

Will Win: Pharrell Williams

BEST FEMALE:

  • Iggy Azalea f/ Charli XCX "Fancy" (Director X, dir.)
  • Beyonce "Partition" (Jake Nava, dir.)
  • Lorde "Royals" (Joel Kefali, dir.)
  • Ariana Grande f/ Iggy Azalea "Problem" (The Young Astronauts, dir.)
  • Katy Perry "Dark Horse" (Mathew Cullen, dir.)

Should Win: The best video here is “Dark Horse” but running this data through the “hot right now matrix”™ says it will be Iggy Azalea f/ Charli XCX “Fancy”

Will Win: Ariana Grande f/ Iggy Azalea “Problem” (either way: it’s Iggy)

BEST POP:

  • Pharrell Williams "Happy" (We Are From L.A., dir.)
  • Iggy Azalea f/ Charli XCX "Fancy" (Director X, dir.)
  • Jason Derulo f/ 2 Chainz "Talk Dirty" (Colin Tilley, dir.)
  • Ariana Grande f/ Iggy Azalea "Problem" (The Young Astronauts, dir.)
  • Avicii f/ Aloe Blacc "Wake Me Up" (Mark Seliger & CB Miller, dir.)

Should Win: Pharrell Williams

Will Win: Pharrell Williams

BEST ROCK:

Should Win: Is Best Rock akin to the Grammy's Polka category at this point? Let's go with Arctic Monkeys “Do I Wanna Know” which is by far the best video here and the the breakthrough rock band of the year (and the most indie of the bunch too, which might explain things to some degree).

Will Win: Black Keys

MTV ARTIST TO WATCH:

Should Win: 5 Seconds of Summer

Will Win: 5 Seconds of Summer (fan voting for the win, people)

BEST COLLABORATION:

  • Beyoncé f/ JAY Z "Drunk In Love" (Hype Williams, dir.)
  • Ariana Grande f/ Iggy Azalea "Problem" (The Young Astronauts, dir.)
  • Pitbull f/ Ke$ha "Timber" (David Rousseau, dir.)
  • Chris Brown f/ Lil Wayne and Tyga "Loyal" (Chris Brown, dir.)
  • Eminem f/ Rihanna "Monster" (Rich Lee, director)
  • Katy Perry "Dark Horse" (Mathew Cullen, dir.)

Should Win: Beyonce x Jay Z

Will Win: Beyonce x Jay Z… I mean, how can you not want these two on-stage together in a potentially unguarded and unreleased moment. Or, maybe the gossip mill is hoping Beyonce will announced some other massive news on this stage.

MTV CLUBLAND AWARD:

Should Win: DJ Snake & Lil Jon "Turn Down For What" 

Will Win: DJ Snake & Lil Jon "Turn Down For What" 

BEST VIDEO WITH A SOCIAL MESSAGE

Should Win: How is “Turn Down For What” not in here?

Will Win: Beyonce “Pretty Hurts”

Tech Categories (below or click read more)

BEST DIRECTION                                                        

Should/Will Win: I should be consistent with "Turn Down For What," but damned if that OK Go video isn't the most impressive and elaborate production of the year. That said, you can swing a wrecking ball and hit a well directed video in this category. 

BEST CINEMATOGRAPHY

Should/Will Win: Arcade Fire "Afterlife" is beautiful, perfect. Wouldn't be surprised if 30 Seconds To Mars wins.

BEST EDITING                                                             

Should/Will Win: "Rap God" and "Your Life Is A Lie" stand out to me... Probably "Rap God" wins.

BEST CHOREOGRAPHY                                                        

  • SIA "Chandelier" Ryan Heffington, choreographer
  • BEYONCE "Partition" Svetlana Kostantinova/Philippe Decouflé, Additional choreography: Danielle Polanco, Frank Gatson, choreographer
  • USHER "Good Kisser" Jamaica Kraft & Todd Sams, choreographer
  • MICHAEL JACKSON f/ JUSTIN TIMBERLAKE "Love Never Felt So Good" Rich + Tone Talauega, choreographer
  • JASON DERULO f/ 2 CHAINZ "Talk Dirty" Amy Allen, choreographer
  • KIESZA "Hideaway" Ljuba Castot, choreographer                            

Should/Will Win: Sia "Chandelier"

BEST ART DIRECTION                                                               

  • DJ SNAKE & LIL JON "Turn Down For What" Jason Kisvarday, art director
  • IGGY AZALEA f/ CHARLI XCX "Fancy" David Courtemarche, art director
  • EMINEM "Rap God" Alex Pacion, art director
  • ARCADE FIRE "Reflektor" Anastasia Masaro, art director
  • TYLER THE CREATOR "Tamale" Tom Lisowski, art director

Should/Will Win: I see this as either "Turn Down For What" or "Fancy"... I think "Fancy" wins since anyone who's seen Clueless can instantly see how well they nailed this video.

BEST VISUAL EFFECTS                                                        

Should/Will Win: Pedantic nerds may disagree, but I take visual effects to be the same as special effects for this category. As such, it's OK Go. 

PS: Don't use this guide to wager on anything. You'll proabably lose money.

Tune into MTV TONIGHT, Sunday, August 24 @ 9pm e/p, for the live broadcast of The MTV Video Music Awards from The Forum, in Inglewood, CA.

Comments

Doug Stern's picture
I agree with most of your should/wills. The VMAs seem to like having certain video win in multiple categories, rather than arranging things so that the wins are spread out more - like the Grammys tend to do. But since us West Coast folks get to actually watch the VMAs live, I'll just be excited to not be completely out of the Twitter-Loop.
Tags: Blog